When Eve (Halee Pierog) is caught kissing her best friend Magda (Daryn Tessier) in the woods the two girls are brought to the local church where the town priest (John McIver) accuses Magda of being a witch. The villagers in the town decide to test if Magda is a witch by binding her and throwing her in a pond. The only person in the town, other than Eve, who advocates for Magda is the local butcher (Tyler Duffy). Will he be able to stop them from drowning an innocent girl?